New York City Scams - A Comprehensive Tourist Safety Guide

New York City Scams - A Comprehensive Tourist Safety Guide #

New York City attracts millions of visitors each year, and unfortunately, where there are tourists, there are scammers looking to exploit them. NYC scams are particularly prevalent because the city’s fast pace, crowded streets, and constant flow of visitors create ideal conditions for con artists to operate. Law enforcement faces significant challenges in cracking down on these schemes due to their mobile nature and the difficulty in catching perpetrators in the act.

This comprehensive guide will help you stay safe during your visit to the Big Apple by identifying the most common scams and providing practical strategies to avoid becoming a victim.

Table of Contents #

  1. Broken Item Scams
  2. Transportation Scams
  3. Street Vendor Scams
  4. Tourist Attraction Scams
  5. Phone and Digital Scams
  6. General Prevention Strategies

Broken Item Scams #

The Classic Broken Bottle Scam #

Alternative versions: Broken glasses, broken medicine bottle, broken insulin, broken cell phone, dropped food

How the scam works:

  1. The scammer deliberately bumps into you, often with an accomplice blocking your escape route
  2. They drop a concealed item (usually a bottle in a paper bag, glasses, or phone)
  3. The scammer immediately accuses you of breaking their valuable item
  4. They demand immediate compensation, often becoming aggressive or intimidating

The setup details:

  • Bottles contain water and are pre-opened to spill dramatically
  • Electronics and glasses are already broken before the “accident”
  • Scammers may claim the item was expensive medicine, rare alcohol, or essential equipment

Prevention strategies:

  1. Disengage immediately - Don’t stop to argue or explain
  2. Walk away confidently - If blocked, loudly call for help
  3. Use strategic vocal tactics - For women, shouting “Help! Don’t touch me!” draws immediate attention. For men, repeatedly yell “Help!” as loudly as possible
  4. Suggest police involvement - If they persist, insist on filing a police report. Real victims won’t hesitate; scammers will disappear
  5. Demand proof - Ask for receipts, security footage, or independent witnesses (not their accomplices)

This scam preys on people’s natural courtesy and guilt, but remember: legitimate accidents don’t require immediate cash payments on the street.

Transportation Scams #

Fake Taxi Operations #

Common locations: Airports (especially LaGuardia and JFK), Penn Station, Port Authority, tourist areas

How the scam works:

  • Unlicensed drivers approach you offering taxi services
  • They lead you to unmarked vehicles, sometimes with fake meters
  • Charges can be 3-10 times the normal rate
  • Payment is demanded upfront or upon arrival with threats if you refuse

Cost comparison (LaGuardia to Manhattan):

  • Public Transit: $2.75 (best option)
  • Uber/Lyft: $25-$50
  • Licensed Taxi: $45-$65 (including tolls)
  • Scam Taxi: $60-$300+

Prevention strategies:

  1. Use ride-sharing apps - Uber and Lyft provide transparent pricing and driver tracking
  2. Take public transportation - NYC’s subway system is extensive and economical
  3. Use official taxi stands - At airports, only use designated taxi queues
  4. Never accept solicited rides - Legitimate taxi drivers don’t approach passengers
  5. Verify taxi credentials - Licensed NYC taxis have specific medallions and identification

Legitimate Taxi Overcharging #

Even in licensed taxis, some drivers may attempt to overcharge through:

  • Unnecessary route extensions
  • False toll charges
  • Fake credit card processing fees
  • “Late night” or “airport” surcharges that don’t exist

Always use GPS navigation on your phone to verify routes, and familiarize yourself with standard taxi rates before traveling.

Street Vendor Scams #

The CD Scam #

How the scam works:

  1. Someone hands you a CD or forces it into your hands
  2. They quickly sign the CD while you’re holding it
  3. They claim you now own it and demand payment
  4. They may become aggressive or call accomplices to surround you

Prevention strategies:

  • Never accept items from strangers - Keep your hands in your pockets or crossed
  • If you accidentally take something - Immediately hand it back without engaging in conversation
  • Use humor to defuse - Say “I’ll charge you $50 for holding services” to confuse the scammer
  • Know your legal rights - You’re not obligated to pay for unsolicited items
  • Threaten police involvement - Scammers will typically retreat when law enforcement is mentioned

The Fake Monk Scam #

How the scam works:

  1. Someone dressed as a Buddhist monk approaches with religious items
  2. They offer prayer beads, books, or “blessed” items as gifts
  3. After you accept, they demand a “donation” for their temple
  4. They exploit people’s reluctance to offend religious sensibilities

Prevention strategies:

  • Recognize the setup - Legitimate monks don’t aggressively solicit donations on street corners
  • Politely decline - Simply say “No thank you” and keep walking
  • Don’t feel guilty - Real religious practitioners respect “no” as an answer
  • If you accidentally accept - Return the item immediately and state you want nothing

Tourist Attraction Scams #

Empire State Building Ticket Scams #

How the scam works:

  • Scammers wear official-looking vests with “Authorized Ticket Agent” badges
  • They approach tourists asking if they’re “going up”
  • They sell overpriced packages including worthless “VIP experiences”
  • The packages often include tickets to outdated movies or simulations, not the actual observatory

Pricing breakdown:

  • Official ticket: $37-$42 for 86th floor
  • Scam package: $60-$120+ (including useless add-ons)

Prevention strategies:

  1. Buy online only - Purchase tickets exclusively from the official Empire State Building website
  2. Ignore street vendors - Anyone approaching you outside is likely a scammer
  3. Use official entrances - Enter through the designated visitor entrance on 34th Street
  4. Recognize fake authority - “Authorized Ticket Agent” badges are meaningless; anyone can print them

Real victim experience: Many tourists report being told they “must” buy packages that include the Skyride (an outdated movie experience) and that individual observatory tickets aren’t available. This is false - you can always buy standard tickets at the official box office.

Statue of Liberty Ferry Scams #

How the scam works:

  1. Fake agents approach near Battery Park or subway exits
  2. They claim to be “official” Statue of Liberty tour representatives
  3. They sell tickets for boats that circle the statue but don’t actually land on Liberty Island
  4. When challenged, they use phrases like “I work here” to imply authority

Prevention strategies:

  • Only one official ferry service exists - Statue Cruises, operated by Hornblower
  • Buy tickets at Castle Clinton - The official ticket office is in the historic fort in Battery Park
  • Beware of ambiguous language - “I work here” could mean anywhere in NYC
  • Verify landing permissions - Only official ferries are authorized to dock at Liberty Island
  • Check official websites - nps.gov/stli has current information and pricing

Phone and Digital Scams #

IRS Impersonation Scam #

How the scam works:

  1. Callers claim to be IRS agents investigating tax fraud
  2. They threaten immediate arrest, deportation, or legal action
  3. They demand immediate payment via gift cards, wire transfers, or cryptocurrency
  4. They insist you can’t discuss the case with anyone else
  5. They may have some personal information to seem legitimate

Red flags:

  • Demanding gift card payments (the IRS never does this)
  • Threatening immediate arrest over the phone
  • Insisting on secrecy
  • Requesting payment through untraceable methods
  • Creating artificial urgency

Prevention strategies:

  1. Hang up immediately - The real IRS communicates primarily through mail
  2. Never pay via gift cards - No legitimate government agency accepts iTunes or Amazon cards as payment
  3. Verify independently - Call the IRS directly using numbers from their official website
  4. Share your experience - Warn others about the attempt
  5. Report the scam - Contact the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA)

Tech Support Scams #

These often involve callers claiming your computer is infected or compromised, demanding remote access and payment for “repairs.”

General Prevention Strategies #

Universal Safety Principles #

  1. Trust your instincts - If something feels wrong, it probably is
  2. Create distance - Physical space gives you time to think and react
  3. Stay alert - Avoid distractions like phones or music in tourist-heavy areas
  4. Travel in groups when possible - Scammers prefer isolated targets
  5. Keep valuables secure - Don’t display expensive items unnecessarily

Communication Tactics #

  1. Use confident body language - Walk with purpose and avoid looking lost
  2. Practice phrases - Have ready responses like “No thank you” or “I’m not interested”
  3. Don’t engage in arguments - Scammers use conversation to build commitment
  4. Make noise when threatened - Loud voices attract attention and deter criminals

Financial Protection #

  1. Carry minimal cash - Use cards for most transactions
  2. Have emergency contacts ready - Know how to reach police, your hotel, and your bank
  3. Understand your rights - You’re never obligated to pay for unsolicited items or services
  4. Document suspicious activity - Take photos or videos if safe to do so

Technology Safety #

  1. Use official apps - Download ride-sharing and navigation apps from legitimate sources
  2. Verify websites - Check URLs carefully when booking attractions online
  3. Protect personal information - Don’t share details with unsolicited callers
  4. Keep devices charged - A dead phone makes you vulnerable

Additional Resources #

Emergency Contacts #

  • NYPD Emergency: 911
  • NYPD Non-Emergency: 311
  • Tourist Hotline: 1-800-NYC-INFO

Official Websites #

  • Empire State Building: esbnyc.com
  • Statue of Liberty: nps.gov/stli
  • NYC Tourism: nycgo.com
  • MTA (Public Transit): mta.info

Reporting Scams #

  • Better Business Bureau: bbb.org
  • Federal Trade Commission: consumer.ftc.gov
  • NYC Department of Consumer Affairs: nyc.gov/consumers

Conclusion #

New York City is an incredible destination with countless legitimate attractions and experiences. By staying informed about common scams and maintaining situational awareness, you can enjoy everything the city has to offer while keeping yourself and your money safe.

Remember that scammers rely on pressure, confusion, and artificial urgency to cloud your judgment. Taking a moment to think clearly and seek verification can save you from becoming a victim. When in doubt, walk away and seek help from official sources.

Share this guide with fellow travelers and help create a safer environment for everyone visiting New York City. The more people know about these scams, the less effective they become.

Stay safe, stay smart, and enjoy your time in the Big Apple!

Crowdsourced Scam Alert Project

Previous Gym Fitness Challenge Scam Market America Scam – Is shop.com a scam? Next